MUD Case Law

The following are decisions of the Irish courts in relation to matters involving Multi-Unit Developments and Owners’ Management Companies.

RAY GREHAN DANNY GREHAN GLENKERRIN HOMES UNLIMITED COMPANY (IN RECEIVERSHIP) MICHAEL MCATEER AND PAUL MCCANN v MAYNOOTH BUSINESS CAMPUS OWNERS’ MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED BY
GUARANTEE [2021] IESCDET 83

PATRICK KELLY, SIMON KELLY, EMMA KELLY, CHRISTOPHER KELLY, JOHN MCCORMACK, BRIAN MCCORMACK, NIALL MCCORMACK, ALAN MCCORMACK, AND PIERSE CONTRACTING LIMITED T/A THE NORTH WALL QUAY PARTNERSHIP v CLARION QUAY MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED BY GUARANTEE [2021] IECA 162

ALTAN MANAGEMENT (GALWAY) LIMITED v TAYLOR ARCHITECTS LIMITED, HUGH GRIFFIN ASSOCIATES AND CORDIL CONSTRUCTION LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP) [2021] IEHC 218

IN THE MATTER OF THE TRUSTEE ACT 1893 ON THE APPLICATION OF BÁRR NA FARRAIGE OWNER’S MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED BY GUARANTEE [2021] IEHC 71

FIONA O’DONNELL v SALTAN PROPERTIES LIMITED AND ELK HOUSE COMPANY IRELAND LIMITED ELK-FERTIGHAUS AG TRADING AS ELK BUILDING SYSTEMS, McHUGH O’COFAIGH, MARK O’REILLY TRADING AS MARK O’REILLY AND ASSOCIATES AND MARK O’REILLY AND ASSOCIATES LIMITED [2020] IECA 226

RAY GREHAN, DANNY GREHAN AND GLENKERRIN HOMES UNLIMITED COMPANY (IN RECEIVERSHIP), MICHAEL McATEER AND PAUL McCANN v MAYNOOTH BUSINESS CAMPUS OWNERS’ MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED BY GUARANTEE [2020] IECA 213

PADDY BURKE (BUILDERS) LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION AND IN RECEIVERSHP) AND TULLYVARAGA MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED AND BY ORDER DATED 27TH NOVEMBER, 2019 STEPHEN TENNANT & PROMONTORIA (ARROW) LIMITED AND MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND EQUALITY [2020] IEHC 170

IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 2014 AND IN THE MATTER OF LANCE INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) AND LANCE HOMES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) AND IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION OF CARL DILLON (LIQUIDATOR) THE HIGH COURT ON CIRCUIT [2017 No. 245 CA] IN THE MATTER OF THE MULTI UNIT DEVELOPMENT ACT, 2011 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 2014 BETWEEN LEE TOWERS MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED AND LANCE INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION), LANCE HOMES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION), AND IRISH IMMIGRATION FUND LIMITED [2019] IEHC 50

BEACON ONE MANAGEMENT COMPANY CLG v BEACON LEISURE INVESTMENTS LTD [2019] IEHC 556

JOSEPH KENNEDY v SWEEPSTAKES OWNERS MANAGEMENT COMPANY CLG [2019] IEHC 552

PEBBLE BEACH OWNERS MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED v SEAMUS NEVILLE AND COLIN NEVILLE AND SEAMUS NEVILLE, LIAM NEVILLE, BRENDAN NEVILLE, COLIN NEVILLE AND ANTHONY NEVILLE TRADING AS THE PEBBLE BEACH HOLIDAY HOME OPERATOR AND BERNARD J. DOYLE AND COLIN J. DOYLE PRACTISING UNDER THE TITLE AND STYLE OF B.J. DOYLE AND COMPANY [2019] IEHC 111

IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 2014 AND IN THE MATTER OF LANCE INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) AND LANCE HOMES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) AND IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION OF CARL DILLON (LIQUIDATOR) THE HIGH COURT ON CIRCUIT [2017 No. 245 CA] IN THE MATTER OF THE MULTI UNIT DEVELOPMENT ACT, 2011 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 2014 BETWEEN LEE TOWERS MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED AND LANCE INVESTMENTS LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION), LANCE HOMES LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION), AND IRISH IMMIGRATION FUND LIMITED [2018] IEHC 444

MICHAEL BEGLEY AND DAMESFIELD LIMITED AND JOHN LALLY AND THE JOLLY M MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED [2018] IEHC 221

FIONA O’DONNELL v MICHAEL RYAN TRADING AS THE RYBO PARTNERSHIP SALTAN PROPERTIES LIMITED ELK HOUSE COMPANY IRELAND LIMITED ELK-FERTIGHAUS AG TRADING AS ELK BUILDING SYSTEMS MCHUGH O’COFAIGH MARK O’REILLY TRADING AS MARK O’REILLY AND ASSOCIATES AND MARK O’REILLY AND ASSOCIATES LIMITED [2017] IEHC 607

IN THE MATTER OF THE COMPANIES ACT 1963-2012 AND IN THE MATTER OF SECTION 280 OF THE COMPANIES ACT 1963 AND IN THE MATTER OF SECTION 290(1), (2), (3) AND (8) OF THE COMPANIES ACT 1963 BETWEEN ANTHONY J. FITZPATRICK IN HIS CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATOR OF BOHERGAR DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED (IN VOLUNTARY LIQUIDATION) AND CUIRT MONARD MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED AND SOUTH TIPPERARY COUNTY COUNCIL [2014] IEHC 136

THE WATERSIDE MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED v BRENDAN KELLY AND ASTA KELLY [2013] IEHC 143

IN THE MATTER OF AN APPLICATION PURSUANT TO SECTION 148(1) NATIONAL ASSET MANAGEMENT AGENCY ACT 2009 AND SECTION 316 OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 1963 AND IN THE MATTER OF JOHN F. RONAN, JOHN FRAHER, RICHARD PRATT AND SEAN WHITE AND IN THE MATTER OF DECLAN TAITE, RECEIVER [2013] IEHC 386

PALACEANNE MANAGEMENT LIMITED v ALLIED IRISH BANKS PLC [2012] IEHC 182

BASINVIEW MANAGEMENT LIMITED & OTHERS v BORG DEVELOPMENTS AND WATERDROP (AN UNLIMITED COMPANY IN LIQUIDATION FORMERLY KNOWN AS COSGRAVE HOMES) AND BERNARD MURPHY [2012] IEHC 380

HOLLYBROOK (BRIGHTON ROAD) MANAGEMENT COMPANY LIMITED AND ALL FIRST PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COMPANY LMIITED AND GINA FARRELL (ALSO KNOWN AS EUGENIA PACELLI) TRADING AS GINA FARRELL CLEANING SERVICES [2011] IEHC 375

RONBOW MANAGEMENT COMPANY LTD v SOROHAN BUILDERS LTD & OTHERS [2010] IEHC 60

IN THE MATTER OF THE VENDOR AND PURCHASER ACT, 1874 AND SECTION 9 THEREOF AND IN THE MATTER OF A CONTRACT FOR THE SALE OF 12, AMIENS SQUARE, DUBLIN, 1, EXECUTED ON OR ABOUT 21st FEBRUARY, 2007 BETWEEN MAHMOUD ZAHEDI AND NOUJ S ZAHEDI AND EAMON McCANN AND PAULA McCANN [2008] IEHC 233

HEIDELSTONE COMPANY LTD -V- TRUSTEES ACT [2006] IEHC 408